|
Post by sensfan77 on Aug 12, 2011 2:06:25 GMT -5
Strengths: All 4 lines are really amazing but your defense can be fixed a bit, the young guns be in hell of a season. Weakness: Young d man might need to wait for them to devleop Rating: 9/10
Easiness to deal with: 8/10 Ability to win a trade 9.5/10
Kane Koivu Kassian Grabner Dubinsky Seguin Schenn Gerbe Butler Hendricks Korpikoski Clark Goligoski Watson Ellerby Dunji Exelby Beauchemin
Varlamov Niittymäki
|
|
|
Post by flojo888 (Devils GM) on Aug 12, 2011 4:56:44 GMT -5
Forwards: 9/10 Explosive and young, theres top end talent, two way depth, and secondary scoring which will all improve substantially in the next few years. Defence: 7.5/10 With only one bonafide top 4 defenceman, it's going to be a sharp learning curve for all the youngsters, but they'll develop to form a solid group of dmen that will be formidable Goaltending: 7/10 with 4 goaltenders hitting the UFA with similar or better ratings, it's hard to give Varlamov a good rating when people have been passing on similar or better. He will be good though, which is the important thing for this team.
Haven't traded with you yet, but you get an 8.5 for winning trades because you take advantage of the youthfullness of players and the impatience of GMs
Nash - Bouchard - Havlat Huselius - Jokinen - Dadonov Hecht - Colborne - Clarkson Pandalfo - Pelley - Novotny
Hedman - Phillips Larsson - Greene Cowen - Salvador
Bryzgalov Lehner
|
|
|
Post by patrickroy99 (Blues GM) on Aug 12, 2011 13:46:18 GMT -5
Forwards: 7/10... definitely improved your depth, still missing some firepower, as Bouchard isnt a top liner and 2nd line is just ok Defence - 8.5/10... any core with both hedman and larsson are sick. Greene and Salvador aren't great Goalies - 8/10 - I'd consider giving Lehner some more time and see if he can pass Bryzgalov (who's underrated)
Haven't really talked any serious trades with you yet
Milan Lucic - David Backes - James Neal Dany Heatley - Drew Stafford - Ales Hemsky Johan Franzen - T.J. Oshie - Erik Cole Daniel Winnik - Chris Kelly - Kyle Brodziak
Dennis Seidenberg - Alex Pietrangelo Kevin Shattenkirk - Vyacheslav Voinov Tim Gleason - Tyler Cuma
Jaroslav Halak FA
|
|
|
Post by habsgm on Aug 15, 2011 15:03:45 GMT -5
Forwards: 9/10 Solid top six that should be able to carry most of the offense. Having Heatley on your second line is a great advantage as well. I don't see any glaring holes, but you could improve a little bit on your bottom but nothing too big. Defense: 8.5/10 I like your D. They're solid all around and will only get better with the development of your younger guys continuing. Goalies: 8/10 Based just on Halak. He's a great goalie, but you need to compliment him with a fine backup (Dubnyks available ). I haven't traded with you yet, so no comment on that. Thomas Vanek - Daniel Briere - Marian Hossa Clarke MacArthur - David Desharnais - Kristian Huselius Nick Spaling - Dave Bolland - Rene Bourque Jamie McGinn - David Legwand - Kyle Wellwood Tomas Kaberle - Ryan Suter Kyle Cumiskey - Brendan Mikkelson Roman Polak - Nick Boynton Yannick Weber Sergei Bobrovsky Dustin Tokarski/Devan Dubnyk
|
|
|
Post by zastu (Hawks Gm) on Aug 15, 2011 15:35:14 GMT -5
Forwards: 7.5/10. I like the top line, 2nd line is alright. bottom 6 could use some upgrades i think. Defence - 7/10. Lack a real shut down dman, which are hard to get i know. Suter decently fits that role i suppose. Personally I dont like kaberle as a top 2 dman, but that could just be me. Goalies - 6.5/10. Trio of young goalies, not really a fan of any of them. Think keeping price would have been ideal but that could just be me again.
Only made one deal earlier in season 1, easy to trade with for sure. Seem to get decent value on most of you're other deals as well.
Sharp - Thornton - Cammalleri Frolik - Backstrom - Zajac Cooke - Bickell - Pacioretty Della Rovere - Eller - Smith
Seabrook - Keith Girardi - Leddy Smid - Elliot
Rinne Salak
|
|
|
Post by dalfan (Avalanche GM) on Aug 16, 2011 0:07:53 GMT -5
Strengths: Top six is killer, 1st line and 2nd line should score often. 3rd is also great. Goaltending and defense also good. Weakness: Four line is a bit skinny, could use some more depth. Rating: 9 to 8.5/10
Easiness to deal with: 10/10 Trade was extremely quick and easy, only done one though. Ability to win a trade N/A haven't looked at too many of your trades.
Gabriel Landeskog - Brad Marchand - Tyler Biggs Ryan Smyth - Matt Duchene - Michael Ryder Antti Miettinen - Ryan O'Reilly - Reggie Smyth Jeff Tambellini - Dainius Zubrus - Ruslan Fedotenko
Cam Fowler - Duncan Siemens Jonas Holos - Trevor Daley Stephane Silas - Paul Martin
Anders Lindback Brian Elliot
|
|
|
Post by taiter32 (Sabres GM) on Aug 16, 2011 16:11:50 GMT -5
Forwards : 7.5/10 Living the depth you have, puttying Smyth and Duchene on the second line will be killer. First line, don't know about Biggs on the top line but who knoes. 3rd line is good, and 4th line is killer! Defense: 8/10 Solid depth, loving that you have Fowler and Daley on seperate pairings. Goalies: 8.5/10 Love your duo you got running.
Havent traded with you Havent followed your trades
Ilya Kovalchuk - Steven Stamkos - Jason Pominville Mason Raymond - Derek Roy - Nicklas Bergfors Viktor Stalberg - Peter Regin - Sean Bergenheim Jim O'Brien - Blair Betts - Arron Asham
Dan Hamhuis - Jordan Leopold Cam Barker - Andrej Sekera Mattias Ohlund - Jonathan Ericsson
Martin Brodeur Jhonas Enroth
|
|
|
Post by braeden (Penguins GM) on Aug 16, 2011 17:03:39 GMT -5
Forwards: 8/10 Solid Top 6 and Bottom 6 but Jim O'Brien isn't really a "solid" Left Winger and I think you could upgrade on him. Defense: 9.5/10 You have great top 4 and bottom 2 defenders. Goalies: 9/10 Brodeur should have a great season but make sure Enroth plays atleast 30 games so you can see what he holds in him. Easiness to deal with: 9/10 Ability to win a trade: 8/10
Line 1: Milan Hejduk - Eric Staal - Patrick Kane Line 2: Brendan Morrow - Wojtek Wolski - Nikita Filatov Line 3: Pascal Dupuis - Tyler Kennedy - Joel Ward Line 4: Evgeny Arthyukhin - TJ Galiardi - David Jones
|
|
|
Post by eamonn (Ducks GM) on Aug 17, 2011 17:37:12 GMT -5
Forwards: 9/10 Top line is very good, 2nd line is solid, really like your 3rd line, 4th line is also pretty solid. Defense: 8.5/10 Solid Goalies: 9.5/10 Fleury is one of the best in the game. Easiness to deal with: N/A Ability to win a trade: N/A
Nazem Kadri - Claude Giroux - Nikolai Kulemin Troy Brouwer - Mikhail Grabovski - David Booth Zac Dalpe - Jacob Josefson - Alexander Steen Matt Moulson - Saku Koivu - Chuck Kobasew Chris Neil - Stephen Reinprecht
Matt Carle - Jason Demers Toni Lydman - Shane O'Brien Keith Ballard - Stuart Percy Andy Sutton
Jonas Hiller Jean-Sébastien Giguère
|
|
|
Post by hockeyfreak (Hurricanes GM) on Aug 17, 2011 22:00:49 GMT -5
strengths: decent depth up front, you can roll four solid lines which is definitely good weaknesses: dont really have much firepower aside from giroux. hopefully kadri develops, but even then, your top two lines dont really have a guy who ties it all together. suggestions: go all in for a big gun. trade a big package like josefsson+kulemin+some of your four 1st rounders next year for that guy. you have enough tweeners that losing kulemin or josefsson wont really make a difference. rating: 6.5/10 easiness to deal with: 8.5/10, always responds which is great and you put up with my shit when i bug you about your players ability to win trades: 6.5/10, your first few trades dealing ryan, getzlaf and perry were questionable, but you've definitely stabiliized after that. Loui Eriksson - Jeff Carter - David Demarro Mike Ribeiro - Tomas Plekanec - Steve Downie Andrew Ladd - RJ Umberger - Andrew Cogliano Eric Fehr - Max Talbot - Ian Laperriere Pat Dwyer Keith Yandle - Stephane Robidas Kyle Quincey - Nick Ebert Ryan Ellis - Jan Hejda Fedor Tyutin Cam Ward Justin Peters
|
|
|
Post by braeden (Penguins GM) on Aug 17, 2011 22:16:30 GMT -5
Forwards: 7/10 I like your top line but I feel Downie and Ladd could switch positions. Otherwise pretty solid. Defence:9/10 You have a really solid D core. Ebert,Ellis and Yandle are both huge. Goalies: 8/10 Ward is good but Peters isn't a great backup.
Easyness to deal with: 7/10 We have some difficulty. Ability to win trades: 9/10 Your team tells you that you win deals easily. It's a great core and you should do well.
Line 1: Milan Hejduk - Eric Staal - Patrick Kane Line 2: Brendan Morrow - Wojtek Wolski - Nikita Filatov Line 3: Pascal Dupuis - Tyler Kennedy - Joel Ward Line 4: Evgeny Arthyukhin - TJ Galiardi - David Jones Marc Staal-Karl Alzner Marc Streit-Jamie Oleksiak Ed Jovanovski-Sami Lepisto Marc-Andre Fleury Brent Johnson
|
|
|
Post by patrickroy99 (Blues GM) on Aug 19, 2011 2:37:12 GMT -5
Forwards: 7/10 Your top line is dangerous, but Wolski and Filitov are just getting by. Depth is solid but not oustanding. Defence: 7.5/10 Above average defence with good depth Goalies: Fleury is one of the best in the game
Easyness to deal with: 5/10 Very difficult, have to coax to get a counter out of Ability to win trades: 6/10 Have lost most of the deals I've seen
James Neal - David Backes - Milan Lucic Dany Heatley - Drew Stafford - Ales Hemsky Johan Franzen - T.J. Oshie - Erik Cole Daniel Winnik - Chris Kelly - Kyle Brodziak
Alex Pietrangelo - Dennis Seidenberg Kevin Shattenkirk - Vyacheslav Voinov Tim Gleason - Tyler Cuma
Jaroslav Halak Mike Smith
|
|