|
Post by Islanders GM (DHL Commish) on Aug 19, 2011 17:31:19 GMT -5
Sparked by the cbox, thought I would start a thread on it.
Post your 3 most Overrated and 3 most Underrated players in DHL based on how good they are in real life...post full stats.
|
|
|
Post by dalfan (Avalanche GM) on Aug 19, 2011 17:37:37 GMT -5
Overrated - Craig Anderson G 31 3187500 4 32 80 82 82 80 82 80 79 84 80 79 69 75 81 80 80
What ducks said.
- Jack Campbell G 20 450000 2 40 79 80 79 81 79 77 77 76 78 74 49 64 79 79 76
Jesus, where the hell did Campbell even come from?
- Erik Johnson D 24 2600000 1 53 81 77 76 82 81 77 82 62 59 51 68 82 78 80 76
I thought he was a bust The kind of defenseman that scores in his on goal. His stats are better than Chara's now.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ygi2SUWwk98
Underrated - Brett Connolly LW 20 390000 2 43 67 71 68 57 61 53 70 63 69 56 65 63 68 57 67
- Zdeno Chara D 35 6500000 7 64 85 74 63 84 83 82 67 76 48 47 80 95 74 83 78
|
|
|
Post by eamonn (Ducks GM) on Aug 19, 2011 17:40:10 GMT -5
Craig Anderson G 31 3187500 4 32 80 82 82 80 82 80 79 84 80 79 69 75 81 80 80
^overrated, one good season doesn't make you an elite goalie.
Alexander Radulov RW 26 1700000 2 27 83 80 78 74 74 66 80 71 74 63 50 69 80 71 75
^this guy isnt even in the NHL..
|
|
|
Post by braeden (Penguins GM) on Aug 19, 2011 17:49:54 GMT -5
Overrated - Dion Phaneuf D 27 6500000 3 70 83 74 73 79 81 86 81 86 55 66 79 86 76 82 80
- Jamie Benn RW 23 5250000 9 42 84 79 79 77 77 78 81 83 76 69 62 76 80 77 78
- Pekka Rinne G 29 3400000 1 27 84 83 82 82 84 83 80 84 84 81 63 75 83 83 81
Underrated - Nicklas Bäckström C 24 6700000 9 33 81 87 84 76 76 71 82 58 65 83 57 72 84 74 77
- Dan Hamhuis D 29 4500000 5 35 70 72 68 78 78 74 74 81 60 51 60 73 70 76 73
- Kris Letang D 25 3500000 3 39 77 83 78 79 79 77 81 81 63 57 66 75 79 78 76
|
|
|
Post by eamonn (Ducks GM) on Aug 19, 2011 17:51:44 GMT -5
Rinne is top 3 goalies in the league.. if anything hes underrated .
|
|
|
Post by hockeyfreak (Hurricanes GM) on Aug 19, 2011 17:54:32 GMT -5
Alexander Radulov RW 26 1700000 2 27 83 80 78 74 74 66 80 71 74 63 50 69 80 71 75 ^this guy isnt even in the NHL.. Radulov would be a point per game player in the NHL. He's rated fine. Overrated: Jonathan Toews C 24 6000000 4 53 83 84 88 82 76 75 85 91 72 86 80 76 85 77 8385 OF? He's a PPG guy, but he's rated like Malkin. He should be around 81 OF, nothing more. Andrej Meszaros D 27 4000000 3 30 78 74 73 78 80 82 78 77 61 58 56 77 75 80 76I'm a huge Mez fan. He's one of my favorite players, but he's definitely not 75 OF or 80 DF. Drop his PL, ST and HI. He's not overly physical. Should be 74 OF and 77 DF. Cal Clutterbuck LW 24 1300000 2 68 79 74 78 74 76 88 80 59 57 61 67 78 77 79 75Not sure how he can be 77 OF. Yeah I know we EHM fans have a collective boner for Clutterbuck, but 77 OF? 74 or 75 is more realistic. Bonus: Brian Boyle C 27 1900000 3 61 78 75 74 76 79 83 70 73 59 75 64 74 75 79 75Since when did Boyle become a top shut down forward in the league? Sorry Army, lol. EDIT: Oh yeah, Phaneuf is definitely overrated. He should be around 74 OF and 78 DF as well. Underrated: Ryan Suter D 27 3500000 1 53 74 80 73 78 78 75 79 85 60 54 63 75 75 77 75CH and PO should be 83 83 at least. He is a top 7 defender in the league and he is rated similarly to the likes of Kyle Quincey. Duncan Keith D 29 5500000 12 33 78 81 77 78 78 70 78 78 77 48 61 80 78 75 76A Norris defender needs to be better than that. He should be around 82 CH and 82 PO. Cant find a 3rd underrated player.
|
|
|
Post by flojo888 (Devils GM) on Aug 19, 2011 18:19:43 GMT -5
[/b][/center] [li] Craig Anderson G 31 3187500 4 32 80 82 82 80 82 80 79 84 80 79 69 75 81 80 80 The guy's value in the real NHL is equivallent to Brian Elliot. That says a lot. He's solid and consistant, but not an elite goaltender by any means. He's like a really really really good back up, who can play consistant and is reliable, but he's not a starter who can win you games. [/li][li]Brent Burns RW 27 3550000 1 60 84 76 75 82 82 82 81 77 58 59 75 78 78 82 77 While I understand switching from D to RW, it doesn't mean he should be rated like a D when he's in RW.. Imo, he should have two different ratings because I don't think theres another forward over 80 defense. And I can tell you this, while he might be 82 defense worthy as a defenceman, he's not 82 defense worthy as a RW [/li][li]Alexandre Burrows RW 31 2000000 2 55 82 78 77 75 76 75 79 84 59 59 62 75 79 75 76 Okay, yes he produces, but does he have the shooting capabilities that warrant an 82? Probably not.. He scores a lot of goals from open areas that are from side to side passes due to the Sedins. He's also not much of a passer, more of a pin it on the boards and rotate. He should be rated more like a 77/76 and is rated more for his production in the NHL than his skill level. Under-rated [/li][li]Jannik Hansen RW 26 1550000 2 28 72 74 73 73 73 76 73 71 71 74 58 70 73 74 73 Ideal third liner, and is much faster, much better at hitting, and a much better checker than these stats. [/li][li]Chris Pronger D 38 4921429 5 57 74 77 68 78 80 78 65 90 58 48 83 81 73 78 77 How does this guy have 78 defense, much less 73 offense? He should be one of the top defensive defenders in the league, 82+ in defense. [/li][li]Niklas Backstrom G 34 6000000 2 44 79 80 77 79 80 79 79 61 79 78 70 74 78 79 78 Probably one of the top goaltenders in the league, except Minnesota really can't get any luck with drafting, signing, or trading (Much less injuries, losing Koivu and Burns for periods over the last few seasons). This guy, if he gets a supporting cast in front of him, will be one of the most difficult goaltenders to beat in the NHL, should be 81 OA in my opinion. For good measure: [/li][li]Ilya Bryzgalov G 32 5666667 9 27 80 80 82 79 82 81 79 72 80 79 57 75 80 80 78 78 overall, but strengths of angles, agility and stickhandling don't create good results. The guy is a stone wall on the bottom half of the net, and while the angles aspect is right he really is good at rebounds as well. Big guy, isn't much for agility or getting out of the net to stick handle. Should be 81 OA, or at least have the stats re-assigned, but I digress and will shut up about it now. [/li][/ul]
|
|
|
Post by eamonn (Ducks GM) on Aug 19, 2011 18:19:48 GMT -5
Yeah I know Radulov is sick but hes not in the NHL..
|
|
|
Post by braeden (Penguins GM) on Aug 19, 2011 18:28:01 GMT -5
Yeah I know Radulov is sick but hes not in the NHL.. That wouldn't make him overrated. lulz
|
|
|
Post by zastu (Hawks Gm) on Aug 19, 2011 18:57:53 GMT -5
how on earth do you consider rinner overrated?
|
|
|
Post by dalfan (Avalanche GM) on Aug 19, 2011 19:35:01 GMT -5
how on earth do you consider rinner overrated? This
|
|
|
Post by habsgm on Aug 19, 2011 19:55:50 GMT -5
in defense of Campbell,n he's going to be a very good goalie. he was amazing for team US in the WJCs.
|
|
|
Post by eamonn (Ducks GM) on Aug 19, 2011 21:26:07 GMT -5
Yeah I know Radulov is sick but hes not in the NHL.. That wouldn't make him overrated. lulz I didn't put that he was overrated. I said he wasn't in the NHL . I came across him while I was looking for overrated players. imo radulov shouldnt even be in the league but ok.
|
|
|
Post by patrickroy99 (Blues GM) on Aug 19, 2011 21:32:09 GMT -5
Rene Bourque RW 30 4000000 2 42 78 74 73 74 72 73 76 78 70 57 66 75 75 73 74 UNDERRATED
Ryan Callahan RW 27 4000000 3 29 80 78 77 78 79 83 79 70 67 68 67 75 78 80 75 OVERRATED
|
|
|
Post by thesituation (Caps GM) on Aug 20, 2011 2:34:29 GMT -5
Kyle Quincey D 27 2750000 2 55 71 78 74 78 79 75 77 80 59 62 64 76 74 77 74 Jack Johnson D 25 4357142 7 52 76 81 74 80 82 76 80 90 64 58 70 80 77 79 79 OVERRATED
Niklas Hjalmarsson D 25 3500000 3 36 56 60 63 76 77 68 76 75 76 56 53 75 59 73 70 Rene Bourque RW 30 4000000 2 42 78 74 73 74 72 73 76 78 70 57 66 75 75 73 74 Duncan Keith D 29 5500000 12 33 78 81 77 78 78 70 78 78 77 48 61 80 78 75 76 Tim Connolly C 31 3500000 3 29 73 78 78 68 71 58 76 80 78 75 66 61 76 65 74 UNDERRATED
|
|
|
Post by heelsox (Wild GM) on Aug 20, 2011 7:50:07 GMT -5
lol Jack Campbell is the best goalie prospect since price to come through.
I'd hope to god the dal in dalfan doesn't stand for Dallas lol.
|
|
|
Post by patrickroy99 (Blues GM) on Aug 20, 2011 13:54:56 GMT -5
OVERRATED Mike Green D 27 5250000 1 49 89 84 81 78 81 80 89 82 62 54 64 75 84 79 79
no way hes that good defensively. prolly should be like a 73 or 74 DF
|
|
|
Post by dbaby (Kings GM) on Aug 21, 2011 3:06:11 GMT -5
callahan is way overrated, anderson should not be an 80 ove and what is up with brent burns being one of the top players all around lol
|
|
|
Post by dalfan (Avalanche GM) on Aug 21, 2011 3:32:38 GMT -5
lol Jack Campbell is the best goalie prospect since price to come through. I'd hope to god the dal in dalfan doesn't stand for Dallas lol. It does
|
|
|
Post by heelsox (Wild GM) on Aug 21, 2011 8:12:09 GMT -5
Derp. Wow, shit. (picture here)
|
|